This was an answer to a post and comment made by Yobachi from his blog Black Perspective:
I struggled with this one, but here goes:
1) The airline industry is far, far different from the automotive industry. Barriers to entry, a service sector versus a manufacturer, lease of planes, hangers and in essence, people vs. ownership of huge fixed assets that dwarf even the Mall of America. The list can go on, but bankruptcy for the car industry is not a neat package. (Hooters ran an airline for a minute – that should tell you everything about the ease of starting an airline.
You got some money? AND have good credit? Go get some leased planes, and a terminal lease, a maintenance crew, jet fuel contract, hotshot pilot(s), boring booking agent, and hot stewardesses, and you’ll be flying in no time…)
2) In fact, they (the big 3, maybe only 1) may never come out – due to contractual obligations, liquidations of assets at a % of actual value (in a deflationary economy) and the damage to the brand. You might not notice, but Toyota, Honda, Kia and other foreign brands have ramped up their marketing of products to take more market share from these failing companies…The big 3 need to reorganize and merge, and innovate, innovate, innovate, but they may be done for.
I just don’t want to hasten their demise…and you shouldn’t either.
3) There is a forest called America that is hurting very badly under an enormous debt of barren trees. ALL total we have now, and its growing, over 52.7 Trillion in debt, public and private. (I.O.U.S.A. -by Addison Wiggin (Author), Kate Incontrera (Author), David Walker (Foreword) )
4) Warren Buffet, Barack’s unofficial financial adviser, relates a story of how China is going to take over America.
Call it: Frugalville versus Consumption City.
The story goes, Consumption City once produced things but after it grew in size and wealth and credit worthiness, it got into consumption of all things from Frugalville. Frugalville made all types of things and save its money received from Consumption City…Soon though, Consumption City no longer had actual wealth, but bought on credit, sending more and more money for those wonderful things…Eventually, since Consumption City had to pay off its debts, it went back to production, however, Frugalville now owned the means of production in Consumption City since it invested in all money received from trading with Consumption City.
This is what is happening…while we think we can think our way out of this mess, we have to start making things others want and get back our money, our wealth in America. While I want this country to be a World Citizen, I also want us to be a producer of items.
5) This is not (completely) about the BIG 3 automakers, but it is about the idea of having a manufacturing base exist still in America. We have shipped off furniture, electronics and other industries solely based on labor cost. Idiocy to believe we can just “think” and “finance” things to make money. People always want products – it is our job to do it competitively.
6) George W. Bush has destroyed our economic vitality under his watch. While these problems existed prior to his administration, no administration has reeked more havoc, across the board, as this one has. This from a Harvard MBA.
Harvard should go out of business if this is what they are still producing…
My goals in this response were:
1) Literally Fly-by-night Airlines are very different from a 100-year old automotive company
2) The United States of America still needs a manufacturing base
3) China is a threat to our national economic security – our trade deficit is outrageous
4) Bush did the most damage in our recent memory to financial dealings
5) Harvard isn’t producing many good minds – unless they are named Barack Obama (I hope.)










